Forge Strategy Lab

Article

When gold breaks a level, how often does the break hold?

Breaking a level is not the same as holding it. Gold can trade beyond the Asian range or the previous day’s high or low, only to reverse and close back inside. Measuring how often price closes beyond a broken level helps show whether continuation or rejection has been more common historically.

These figures do not predict what will happen after the next break, and they do not determine the correct stop distance by themselves. They provide context that can be combined with a clearly defined entry, invalidation point and tested exit rules.

Our figures cover one-minute XAU/USD prices across 2,633 complete trading days from 15 August 2016 to 6 November 2026, using the same price history as the Forge backtester.

Asian range breakouts: how often does the first break hold?

For this analysis, Forge defines the Asian range as the high and low recorded between the 23:00 UK reopen and 07:00 UK. Any movement beyond that range after 07:00 and before the 22:00 close counts as a break.

This is the statistical range used for this report. It should not be confused with my personal Asian range, which I mark from 01:00 to 05:15 UK time when developing and trading my own strategies.

Our full article on how often gold breaks its Asian range covers the frequency in more detail. Over the latest 12 months, from 7 November 2025 to 6 November 2026, price traded beyond the Forge Asian high or low after 07:00 on 93% of the 258 complete trading days.

The more useful question for trade planning is what happened after the first side was broken. Of the 241 days that broke at least one side of the Asian range:

  • 54% closed beyond the side that broke first, meaning the initial break held at the 22:00 close.
  • 37% closed back inside the Asian range, meaning the initial break failed to hold.
  • 8% closed beyond the opposite side after first breaking in the other direction.

The percentages do not total exactly 100% because they are rounded. The initial break held on more than half of the qualifying days, but failed or reversed to the opposite side often enough that neither outcome should be treated as automatic.

What a failed Asian range break looks like

A failed break occurs when price trades beyond the Asian high or low and later closes back inside the range. The move beyond the level may be large enough to trigger breakout entries before price reverses.

Closing back inside does not necessarily mean price returned to its original starting point or travelled across the entire range. It only means the 22:00 closing price finished between the measured Asian high and low.

The timing of the first break also varied. The median first-break time was 08:45 UK, and 54% of first breaks occurred before 09:00. The 07:00 hour alone contained 37% of first breaks.

An early break leaves more of the day available for either continuation or reversal, but its timing alone does not tell us which outcome will follow.

My approach after an Asian range break

I do not try to decide within the first few minutes whether a break will continue. I want to see how the candle closes around the level. A strong close beyond it supports continuation, while a sweep followed by an M15 close back inside is the type of rejection I look for before considering a move in the opposite direction.

Previous day’s high and low: does the break close beyond?

Our figures on how often gold takes out yesterday’s high or low show that price traded above the previous day’s high, below its low or through both on 88% of days during the latest 12 months. Twelve per cent remained inside the previous day’s range.

Among the days that traded above the previous day’s high, 48% closed above that level. Across the complete dataset since 2016, the corresponding figure was 52%.

Among the days that traded below the previous day’s low, 51% closed below it. Across the complete dataset since 2016, the corresponding figure was 47%.

These close rates sit close to 50% in both directions. The figures therefore provide little support for assuming that every move through the previous day’s high or low will continue into the close.

A close beyond the level across the whole trading day is also different from a valid intraday entry. A break may offer a profitable move before later reversing, while another may close beyond the level only after initially moving deeply against the breakout direction.

My approach at the previous day’s levels

Around the previous day’s high or low, I look at whether price closes through the level with momentum or merely sweeps it and closes back inside. A sweep and rejection can support a trade back in the opposite direction, while a confirmed close beyond the level followed by price holding above or below it gives the breakout more credibility.

Planning stops and targets around these figures

The hold and failure percentages describe where the day eventually closed. They do not show how far price moved beyond the level first, how deeply it retraced or where a suitable stop should have been placed.

It would therefore be misleading to conclude that stops should automatically be widened because 37% of Asian-range breaks closed back inside. A stop should sit at the point where the specific setup is invalidated, and its effectiveness should be tested using the complete intraday price path rather than the closing result alone.

The average Forge Asian range over the latest 12 months was $64.22 (642 pips), while the average complete daily range was $111.83 (1,118 pips). These figures show the amount of movement gold has recently covered, but neither number is automatically an appropriate stop or target.

My approach when the Asian range is wide

When the Asian range is wider than usual, I do not automatically widen my stop or increase the amount at risk. If the setup needs a wider stop, I reduce the lot size so the potential loss stays the same. If the range falls outside the conditions the strategy was tested on, I would rather skip the trade than change the rules during the session.

Does the day of the week change anything?

The share of days that broke at least one side of the Forge Asian range varied by weekday during the latest 12 months:

  • Monday: 85%
  • Tuesday: 100%
  • Wednesday: 96%
  • Thursday: 92%
  • Friday: 94%

These figures measure how often a break occurred, not whether it produced a profitable trade or held into the close. Tuesday recorded a break on every qualifying day in this particular 12-month sample, but that does not guarantee that every future Tuesday will break the range.

My approach to Monday

I treat Monday differently because it begins the new trading week and the previous-day levels come from Friday. I use Friday’s high and low alongside the emerging weekly structure, then wait for Monday to show direction rather than assuming the Asian range must break.

Putting the figures into practice

The figures show that Asian-range and previous-day breaks are common, but holding beyond the level is much less certain. A level being crossed is therefore only one part of a setup.

For a breakout strategy, the entry, candle close, retest rules, stop and target should be tested together. For a rejection strategy, the sweep and close back inside should be defined precisely rather than identified afterwards by eye.

I use my own 01:00-05:15 Asian range as a reference for my strategies, with my main London window running from 08:00 to 11:00 and my New York window from 15:00 to 18:00. Those are my personal trading windows and are separate from the broader 23:00-07:00 range used to produce the statistics in this article.

The aim is not to predict every break correctly. It is to define what counts as continuation, what counts as rejection and how much risk the strategy accepts when either outcome occurs.

About Glen Hall

Glen Hall trades gold (XAU/USD) and is a founding member of Forge Strategy Lab. He develops and tests systematic gold strategies, using backtesting and forward testing to understand what works, what doesn't, and how strategies behave in changing market conditions.

This page is education, not financial advice. The figures describe how gold has moved in the past; they do not predict how it will move next. Trading involves risk and you can lose more than you expect. Never risk money you cannot afford to lose.

Turn a pattern into a tested strategy.

Build a gold strategy around what you have just read, without code, and backtest it on the same years of prices. Free to start, no card required.

Start free